Anastasia Antonov has written directly to President Trump asking him to pressure Vladimir Putin to free her father, Aleksandr Antonov, 66, an American citizen sentenced to six years in Russian prison on what she believes are fabricated charges designed to target him for his U.S. citizenship.
Sign in or create a free account.
Gain access to limited free articles, news alerts, and morning briefings.
By continuing, you agree to the Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.
Enjoy unlimited access to Insider Wire.
See subscription optionsThe naturalized American citizen was arrested March 5, 2025 at Moscow's Sheremetyevo International Airport during a routine passport checkpoint. Border officers discovered his U.S. passport and alleged they found Telegram messages on his phone containing anti-Russian sentiment. Russian prosecutors charged him under Article 205.2 of the criminal code, related to inciting terrorism and extremism. His trial concluded on April 18, 2025, with the Basmanny District Court delivering the six-year sentence.
Antonov immigrated from the Soviet Union in the 1990s, settling in Cleveland where he worked as an electrical engineer before starting a small manufacturing business. He had been making quarterly business trips to Ukraine and Russia since 2018, primarily importing industrial equipment. His daughter told CBS News she "felt it was time" to elevate her father's case directly to the president, indicating frustration with the State Department's slow response while Trump simultaneously navigates complex diplomatic challenges with Chinese investment concerns and ongoing tensions with rival powers.
State Department Split on Wrongful Detention
Three U.S. officials told CBS News there is an internal battle at the State Department over whether to designate Antonov as wrongfully detained — a classification that would signal the U.S. believes the charges are fabricated and prioritize his case for prisoner exchanges. The designation would place him alongside other high-profile cases like journalist Evan Gershkovich, who was released in August 2024 as part of a 24-person prisoner swap.
Several officials from the Bureau of Consular Affairs recommended in a March 28, 2025 memo to Secretary of State Marco Rubio's top counselor that Antonov had been wrongly detained. The memo cited the arbitrary nature of his arrest, lack of evidence supporting terrorism charges, and patterns consistent with Russia's targeting of dual nationals. However, other State Department diplomats from the European and Eurasian Affairs bureau opposed the designation, fearing it would inflame tensions with Russia during ongoing Ukraine war diplomacy, according to two officials briefed on the case.
The authority to grant wrongful detention status rests with Rubio. Former Special Presidential Envoy for Hostage Affairs Roger Carstens explained that "split memos" can complicate matters when regional departments disagree, making it harder to persuade a secretary of state even when evidence overwhelmingly supports the legal and consular teams' recommendations. The designation would unlock resources from the Special Presidential Envoy for Hostage Affairs office and elevate the case to National Security Council level discussions.
Pattern of Targeting American Citizens
Antonov's case fits a broader pattern of Russia detaining American citizens on questionable charges. Since 2021, Russia has arrested at least 12 American citizens, including former Marine Paul Whelan and basketball star Brittney Griner. Intelligence analysts believe Moscow uses these detentions as leverage in broader diplomatic negotiations, particularly regarding sanctions relief and prisoner exchanges.
The timing of Antonov's arrest came just weeks before the second anniversary of Russia's invasion of Ukraine, as Congress was debating a $61 billion aid package for Kyiv. Russian media outlets highlighted his American citizenship, suggesting authorities intended to use his case for political purposes.
High-Level Talks Include Antonov Case
Despite the State Department's indecision, a former senior government official told CBS News that U.S. officials have assured the family that Russia cases are a priority. Antonov is "on the list" given to U.S. envoy Steve Witkoff to discuss with Putin adviser Kiril Dmitriev, with Jared Kushner also participating in those talks. The list includes seven American citizens currently held in Russian custody.
This represents part of Trump's broader strategy of engaging directly with adversarial leaders, similar to his approach with high-stakes summit diplomacy with China's Xi Jinping on trade and security issues. Trump has previously claimed he could secure releases through personal relationships with foreign leaders, pointing to prisoner exchanges during his first term.
What's Next
The next decision point comes May 15, 2025, when Secretary Rubio must respond to the competing State Department recommendations on Antonov's wrongful detention status. Witkoff is scheduled for another round of talks with Russian officials in late May, which could include discussions of prisoner exchanges. Antonov's family has hired Washington attorney Jonathan Franks, who represented other wrongfully detained Americans, and plans to meet with National Security Council officials next week to press their case directly.
