A paramedic testified she felt overwhelming disbelief while watching a police officer fatally taser Clare Nowland, a 95-year-old woman with dementia, at a New South Wales nursing home last year. The paramedic, whose identity has been suppressed by the coroner, described the moment as one of "shock and disbelief" during her testimony at the Coroner's Court of NSW in Sydney this week.
Sign in or create a free account.
Gain access to limited free articles, news alerts, and morning briefings.
By continuing, you agree to the Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.
Enjoy unlimited access to Insider Wire.
See subscription optionsThen-senior constable Kristian James Samuel White fired his weapon at Nowland after being called to Yallambee Lodge nursing home in Cooma on May 17, 2023. The incident occurred at approximately 4:33 AM when staff reported concerns about Nowland's behavior during the night shift. White discharged his taser at the elderly woman, who fell backward and struck her head on the floor. She died seven days later at Cooma District Hospital on May 24, 2023.
Emergency Response Details Emerge
The paramedic's testimony comes as part of a coroner's inquest examining the elderly woman's death, as Insider Wire previously reported. Court documents show that two paramedics and multiple police officers were present at the scene when White deployed his taser. The paramedic witness described watching the incident unfold in real time, expressing her immediate reaction of disbelief that force would be used against someone so elderly and frail.
NSW Police had been called to Yallambee Lodge after nursing staff reported that Nowland was holding a steak knife and displaying agitated behavior. The facility, operated by Southern Cross Care, houses approximately 90 residents and specializes in aged care services including dementia support. White had been with NSW Police for 12 years at the time of the incident and was stationed at Monaro Police District.
The coronial inquest, presided over by Deputy State Coroner Teresa O'Sullivan, began hearing evidence in November 2024. The proceeding is examining the circumstances surrounding Nowland's death and whether it could have been prevented through different protocols or training.
Training Gap Under Scrutiny
The coroner is examining whether better dementia training for aged care staff, police officers, and ambulance personnel could have prevented the fatal encounter. Current NSW Police training includes mental health first aid components, but specialized dementia response protocols remain limited. The inquest has heard that White received standard police academy training but no specific instruction on managing elderly dementia patients.
Aged care workers at Yallambee Lodge typically undergo dementia-specific training that emphasizes patience, redirection, and de-escalation techniques. These methods contrast sharply with standard police crowd control tactics, creating potential conflicts when emergency services are called to nursing facilities.
The case raises questions about how law enforcement responds to vulnerable elderly patients experiencing dementia-related episodes. Expert witnesses are expected to testify about best practices for managing behavioral symptoms of dementia, which affect up to 90% of people with the condition at some point.
Pattern of Concern in Aged Care
White's decision to deploy his taser against a frail elderly woman has drawn national attention in Australia, highlighting the intersection of policing methods and aged care protocols. This incident follows a pattern of increased police involvement in aged care facilities across NSW, with call-outs to nursing homes rising 23% between 2020 and 2023 according to police data.
The nursing home setting adds another layer of complexity, as staff trained in dementia care typically use de-escalation techniques rather than force. Industry guidelines from Dementia Australia recommend environmental modifications, communication strategies, and medication reviews before considering any physical intervention.
Australia's aging population compounds these challenges, with dementia cases projected to reach 812,500 by 2058. The Aged Care Royal Commission recommended improved staff training and better integration between health services, but implementation has been uneven across the sector.
Next Steps in Legal Process
The inquest findings could reshape how Australian emergency services handle calls involving dementia patients. Deputy Coroner O'Sullivan has indicated she will examine whether new protocols should mandate mental health professionals or specialized police units for aged care calls.
The coroner's examination will determine whether systemic changes in training and response procedures are needed to prevent similar tragedies. White faces a separate criminal case, with his matter scheduled for mention in Cooma Local Court on February 14, 2025.
The coronial inquest is expected to continue through early 2025, with final recommendations due by March. The coroner has the power to make binding recommendations about police training, aged care protocols, and inter-agency coordination procedures.
